This blog post is the second of a series of three relating to successful color matching for screen printing. The author of this very informative article is Mike Ukena, and he is a part of the Union Ink Company.
COLOR
Color is the most subjective criteria we have to deal with as screen printers. Everyone seems to be an expert. Everyone sees things a little differently, and color varies depending on the light you are viewing it in. There are expensive machines available that will analyze a color sample and tell you exactly what it is so you can match it... the key word here being expensive.
Most people go by eye, and that is most likely what the customer is going to use to approve a sample, so it is still the overriding criteria in any matching system. Plus, some of the man made colors that we use in screen printing throw off the expensive measuring equipment. Fluorescent/neon colors are very difficult for most of the devices to measure, especially when they are a part of an ink mix.
The key in any shop is a system that works and meets your customer's needs. Whether it is an expensive measuring device or a good eye is not as important as being able to hit a color. And, once you have matched a color, can you do it again and again?
MATCHING SYSTEMS
Most of the major manufacturers have at least one Pantone ink matching system. The advantage to these systems is that they allow you to make exactly what you need for an order. With a little practice, most ink departments can cut their waste by over 50% by using a matching system.
Matching systems are not expensive for the printer to use. The base inks are about the same price and pre-mixed inks and the only extra equipment that is required is an accurate weighing scale and a mixer. A smaller printer can be up and running with a matching system starter kit, a scale, and a small mixer for under $1,000. Larger printers can expand upon the base concept by adding dispensing equipment to speed up the process and to allow for larger batches. These systems run as much as $50,000 but are often subsidized by the ink manufacturer in return for a commitment to their ink.
The disadvantage to these systems is they are either opaque or general purpose, but not both. A small shop can do just fine with an opaque system and the use of a soft hand extender base (a product which reduces the opacity of the ink and makes it more economical to use on lighter fabrics) when printing on light garments. A large shop can justify two systems.
Color matching systems are design to allow a printer to mix specific color shades from a group of basic colors. They are most commonly used to simulate specific Pantone Matching System (PMS) colors. The Pantone colors are the most common system used by advertising agencies, corporations, advertising specialty companies and clothing designers to designate the colors that they want to use on a screen printed product.
TWO DISTINCT MATCHING SYSTEM TYPES
There are two types of systems in use. The differ greatly in philosophy. The two types are generally referred to as "finished ink" systems and "base and pigment" systems.
A finished ink system relies on base inks that are in an RFU (ready to use) formulation. These inks can actually be used right out of the bucket as is. If you like the color, it is printable without mixing.
Base/pigment systems rely on ink bases into which the printer adds a series of pigment concentrates to achieve a color. These systems cannot be used right out of the bucket.
WHICH TYPE IS BETTER?
The usual "it depends" fits real nice right here. Both types have their advantages and disadvantages. Finished ink systems are much easier to use and in general, they are a little less expensive overall. They are easier because it is much more difficult to make a big mixing mistake. If you add too much of a specific color, it is not a huge deal to adjust the other colors to the corrected formula. On the other hand, a finished ink system is less flexible in terms of base formulation. You get the base that the ink is made in and that's it. You can adjust opacity downward, you can put in additives to make it into one of several specialty formulations, but overall, it is more restrictive in terms of different specialty inks that can be made from it.
Stay tuned for part three!